Returns Management
July 10, 2024

Combatting Return Fraud: Essential Insights for Online Retailers


As online retail expands, so does return fraud, affecting profitability and trust. Here's a breakdown of common scams and how to counter them.

What is Return Fraud?

Return fraud manipulates refund policies for profit. Common tactics include "wardrobing" (wearing items once and returning them) and claiming non-receipt of delivered goods. Distinguish return fraud from refund fraud (false refund claims) and return abuse (exploiting return policies).

12 Common Return Fraud Tactics:

  1. Empty Box Returns: Returning a package without the product.
  2. Stolen Item Returns: Returning stolen goods with fake receipts.
  3. Price Switching: Swapping price tags for higher refunds.
  4. Wardrobing: Using items briefly then returning.
  5. Bracketing: Buying multiple items to try at home, returning most.
  6. “Item Not Received” Scam: Falsely claiming non-delivery.
  7. Cross-Retailer Returns: Exploiting price differences across retailers.
  8. Return Receipt Fraud: Using fake receipts for refunds.
  9. Price Arbitrage: Returning cheaper items as expensive ones.
  10. Opportunism: Returning items without valid reasons.
  11. Open-Box Fraud: Returning opened items to repurchase at discounts.
  12. Employee Fraud: Collusion between employees and fraudsters.

8 Ways to Avoid Return Frauds:

  1. Use a Return Authorization System: Authenticate returns to ensure legitimacy.
  2. Check Return History: Identify and block serial returners.
  3. Monitor Return Rates: Detect and investigate significant changes.
  4. Optimize Your Return Policy: Balance customer satisfaction and fraud prevention.
  5. Send Delivery Confirmations: Provide proof of delivery to prevent false claims.
  6. Track Reverse Shipping: Monitor return shipments for anomalies.
  7. Adopt Fraud Prevention Solutions: Utilize advanced technologies for detection.
  8. Educate Your Staff: Train employees to recognize and handle fraud.

FAQs on Return Fraud:

  • Is return fraud illegal? Yes, it's fraudulent and subject to prosecution.
  • Is it illegal to return items to a different store? Yes, if intended to deceive.
  • Jail time for refund fraud? Varies; could range from months to years.
  • How to detect return fraud? Use data analytics, RFID tags, and smart packaging.

Reduce Return Frauds with Exchange It:

Exchange It offers a comprehensive returns management system, verifying identities, analyzing return requests, and setting eligibility rules to prevent fraud. Install Exchange It on Shopify to enhance your return operations.

Continue reading

Got questions? We have answers.